Inside Scoop Breaking News Video Blog Index Participate Humor
Home Bangkok Pundit Thailand and Refugees : An UPDATE
+ Follow Me

Bangkok Pundit

BP

Location: Bangkok, Thailand

My Posts | My RSS feed


Thailand and Refugees : An UPDATE

 
Jan. 17 2009 - 12:07 am
View comments (0)


UPDATE: It is the lead news item on ThaiPBS evening news - they focus on the BBC story and give a reasonable accurate summation of the BBC news articles. Abhisit has asked the Foreign Ministry to explain as it affects the image of the country and to find out the facts. Gen. Anupong denied the news, but said there will be an investigation. Both Abhisit and the Navy Chief have said it is a security issue.

BP: It was not only the lead item, but it was about 10 minutes in length.

First, credit should go to PhuketWan who from what BP understands broke the story - the two journalists who wrote the SCMP story write for PhuketWan. PhuketWan have a handy page here with plenty of coverage of the story. It is definitely worth a read.

In an update to the post the other day on the Rohingya refugees and their treatment by the Thai military, the BBC is all over the story and have three articles on it, with two being from India.

The first story from India:
Thai soldiers are detaining illegal migrants from Bangladesh and Burma and forcing them back out to sea in boats without engines, survivors say.

Survivors say their hands were tied and they were towed out to sea with little or no food or water.

About 500 migrants are now recovering from acute dehydration in India's Andaman islands and the Indonesian province of Aceh.

Thai officials were not immediately available for comment.

But sources in the police and army confirmed to the BBC's Jonathan Head in Bangkok that asylum seekers are being pushed out to sea. They did not provide further details about the practice.

Survivors rescued by Indian coast guards say hundreds of other asylum-seekers are still missing after leaBoldving Bangladesh and Burma since the end of November.

They told the BBC that they paid agents to take them to Thailand by boat so that they could have a better life.

They said that the Thai authorities detained many of them in Koh Sai Daeng island.

"Thai soldiers tied up our hands and then put us in boats without engines. These were towed into the high sea by motorised boats and left to drift," said Zaw Win, a survivor rescued by Indian coast guards off the coast of Little Andamans after drifting for 12 days.

"We were without food and water. The Thai soldiers clearly wanted us to die on the boats," Win told the BBC by telephone from a camp where survivors are being cared for.

Other survivors said that about 400 migrants were put on a huge boat by soldiers. It was equipped with only two bags of rice and two drums of drinking water.

"The food and water ran out in two days. After that we were starving for nearly 15 days before we saw a lighthouse and jumped into the sea and tried swimming ashore," Mohammed Said told the BBC.

This group of migrants was also rescued by the Indian coast guards and put into relief camps.

The second article has an account from one of the survivors who estimates that there were 400 people on a couple of different boats. Only around 100 or so have been found.

The third article is from Jonathan Head:
Privately, some Thai military and police sources have admitted to the BBC that this has been happening - they say the escalating numbers of Rohingyas reaching Thailand from Burma or Bangladesh are seen as a security risk, because of fears they may include Islamic militants.

The reason they disable their engines, they say, is to prevent them trying to come back to Thailand.

Refugee welfare groups have condemned the practice as inhumane.

The Thai government says it has ordered an investigation of the incident, but stressed that is committed to humanitarian principles in handling illegal immigration.

BP: This is not something that will go away. Seth in the NYT notes on how in one instance 400 or so were persuaded to be put on the boat:
In one case last month, the reports say, 410 Rohingya migrants were taken out to sea on a Thai Navy vessel and forced onto an open barge with just four barrels of water and two sacks of rice.

Four people were thrown overboard with their hands and feet tied, in order to encourage the others to board the barge, according to the reports.

CNN notes that the UN is becoming involved:
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees says it is "concerned" about the fate of the Muslim ethnic minority Rohingya people, who have fled from Myanmar's border with Bangladesh.

The agency says it has written a formal note to the Thai Ministry of Foreign Affairs asking for clarification of what is happening.

CNN spoke to one Australian tourist, who declined to be named for fear of being barred from Thailand, who says boat-people were "whipped" by Thai guards on popular diving resort island in the Similan Archipelago last month

The official denials are coming. AP:
"We deport illegal immigrants, but we adhere to internationally accepted practice," Immigration police chief Lt. Gen. Chatchawal Suksomjit said.

While official sources in Thailand have confirmed to the BBC that the refugees were forced back out to sea, the immigration service deny such a policy. “Thai immigration office will never send illegal immigrants back to their countries by putting them back in the boat then let them go,” Police Lieutenant General Chatchawal Suksomjit, a commander of the Thailand Immigration Office, told reporters.

BP: Classic denial which means nothing. The Thai Immigration office may not do this and no one is accusing them of this, but what about the military...

The Nation has the denial by the Navy:
Navy chief Admiral Kamthorn Phumhiran on Friday dismissed a BBC report claiming Thai military had ill-treated the Rohingyas from Burma and Bangladesh who sought work or asylum by pushing them out to sea and setting them adrift.

"The Royal Thai Navy did not badly treated the Rohingyas. There was no setting them adrift as alleged," he said.

Under the military convention, the navy is obligated to rescue enemies from a sunken ship, he said, arguing there is no reason to mistreat the migrants landing on the Thai shore.

In the incident in question, the navy was notified by marine park rangers about the Rohingyas at Kon Sai Daeng, Ranong, he said.

A group of 20 navymen were dispatched to investigate and they found more than 100 Rohingyas, prompting the order for the migrants to lie down for safety reason, he said.

He added that the picture depicting navymen standing over the rows of migrants lying down should not be construed as mistreatment but a standard procedure to detain a large number of people.

The Rohingyas were brought to a shelter with food and water, he said. Afterwards, the navy alerted the immigration police and handed over the custody. 

BP: Can't find any story The Nation has on the actual allegations (ok just as about to post there is a brief article today). The Bangkok Post also has the denial and some brief details of the allegations.

Foreign Ministry has issued a statement which talks of people investigating what happened.

There has been coverage in the Thai language print media. Matichon has a story with the denial by the Navy although it does mention details of the BBC article. Thai Rath has the denial although limited details of the BBC story and accounts of survivors. At the end of the article, we see that Abhisit has ordered some kind of investigation into the issue.

Lets be clear that there is no indication that Abhisit knows anything about this and BP is not implicating Abhisit in this at all. As is increasingly clear, the military and the Thai bureaucracy are a law unto themselves. However, it is a "problem" that Abhisit now faces. To be honest, it is problem with the international community. So far BP has not heard one single Thai NGO person say anything about this.

BP: Will the NGO community speak up? Will the Thai media investigate what the military is doing? We have ThaiPBS now, wasn't it set up for this kind of investigation? What will become of the government investigation?  Kasit is being rather quiet on this issue.*

*AP reports on the Foreign Ministry statement:
Thailand's foreign minister promised in January, before taking office, that Thailand would pursue a 'clean and humane' foreign policy. He contrasted this with what he called the 'tainted' and self-serving foreign policies persuaded by the former regime.



  Comment It |     |    Email it    Print it   


Related Stories


Of product and process innovation (story by Atanu Dey on India's Development)
Man well and truly smapped (story by The ShadowLands)
Hell hath no fury, and Teresa goes on suing spree (story by Rocky's Bru)
AdTech, AdGate and Blue Collar Blogging (story by An American Professor in China)
NORMAN MAILER, MURDER AND MORAL FRIVOLITY (story by RWDB - JF Beck)
Diesel and Gasohol Prices to Fall Tomorrow (story by Bangkok Pundit)


Comments


No comments yet.




Name:

E-mail:
(optional)
Comment:

Allowed HTML tags: <B></B>, <I></I>, <A></A>
Are you human? 




designed by Fusion