Inside Scoop Breaking News Video Blog Index Participate Humor
Home Bangkok Pundit Thailand 'apology' advertisement banned
+ Follow Me

Bangkok Pundit

BP

Location: Bangkok, Thailand

My Posts | My RSS feed


Thailand 'apology' advertisement banned

Thailand 'apology' advertisement banned
+ enlarge
Jul. 19 2010 - 02:57 am
View comments (7)

4


By Madmue Bitbaak,

A public ruckus has erupted after an advertisement focusing on the national political crisis has been banned. The Nation reports,

The ban of a television commercial entitled "Kor Thod Pra Thet Thai" (Apologise Thailand) from free television has caused a flood of criticism in social media and web-boards. But there was still no explanation from the television station joint censorship committee which ordered the ban. The advertisement was created by the "Positive Network", a new initiative by many major communication groups in Thailand. The network consists of people from advertising, public relations, media agencies, and cable and TV associations.

As to the reason why the censorship board has banned the controversial advertisement, The Nation says,

"According to Kom Chad Luek newspaper, the committee ordered the ban because they thought the message and pictures used in the ad were too extreme and risked defamation. The paper quoted Bhanu Inkawat, one of the ad's creators and founder of the network as saying the panel told him they were concerned about the way the story was told and the order of the pictures.

What is so deeply controversial and threatening to national security that the government doesn't want you to see it? Well ironically the video is getting over one-hundered thousand hits on YouTube and has been uploaded on to numerous Thai websites, even CRES has joined in! In case you haven't seen it, here it is with English translation below it (c/o The Nation):

 "Did we do anything wrong? Did we handle anything too harshly? Did we listen to only one side of the story? Did we perform our duties? Did we really think of people? Were we corrupt? Did we take too much? Did the media make people better informed? Did our society deteriorate? Did we love money more than the rightness? And did we only wait for help? If there was anyone to blame, it would be all of us. Apologise Thailand. And if there was anyone who can fix the problems, it would be all Thais. Keep the loss in mind and turn it into our force."

The government's "growing authoritarian image" received an additional boost over the weekend when police arrested Natee an attendee at a Ratchaprasong commemoration/re-enactment ceremony. Natee's arrest comes on the heels of last week's political arrest of Mirror founder Sombat  Boonngamanong for tying a ribbon at Ratchaprasong in violation of the emergency decree. Not much yet in the press (Sunday?) on Natee, but Twitter has taken care of that with @terryfrd (BKK Post) and illustrious Thai tweetaholic @on_off_course. Natee reportedly is free on bail. Sombat has also reemerged at Ratchaprasong (YouTube video)  Natee's "antics"--shouting he is here alone and not in defiance of the emergency law--is below:

 

 



  Comment It |     |    Email it    Print it   


Related Stories


In Malaysia, the Government fears blogs (story by Rocky's Bru)
Government Coalition: Rushed “High Level” Meeting on Big Jiew (story by Thai Intelligent News)
Flushing Away a Million Dollars (story by Big White Guy)
Record drought ravages southern China (story by GreenFudge)
Western Australia gov't still badgering motorists despite fall in road deaths (story by RWDB - JF Beck)
Australian government accused of pressuring refugee status reviewers (story by RWDB - JF Beck)


Comments



by StanG
on 07/19/2010 09:34 am
http://siampolitics.wordpress.com/

Government denies banning the video:

http://thainews.prd.go.th/en/news.php?id=255307180030

And here's the video on CRES own website:

http://www.capothai.org/capothai/khxthos-prathesthiy


by Steve
on 07/19/2010 01:06 pm

Version of the "apology" video with English sub-titles at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dNIu8_-iU8


by Anonymous
on 07/19/2010 06:31 pm

Strikes me that its message is quite pro status quo really. Ignoring the sickly sweet voice over what I get from the last few images is the message is to get back to your buffalo peasants and leave the educated (images of libraries, teachers etc) to get on with business as usual...
I'd imagine the objectionable content in it was simply that there is an attempt to apportion blame a little bit more even handedly. But promoting a genuine attempt at reconciliation is missing the point. The government and its allies need to find the people to blame. Scapegoats, conspiracies and subversion are the key points that should be emphasized and they haven't been here.


by Anonymous1789
on 07/20/2010 04:56 am

Funny how middle class Thais get more upset by the arrest of a couple activists and the banning of some crappy video (oh god, it's too awful for words) than the shooting dead of 90 of their fellow citizens.


by Anonymous
on 07/20/2010 07:50 am

Of course this is defamatory. By asking these questions without providing a definitive, the video dares to remind the public that the questions themselves are open-ended.

And we can't have that! It simply would not do. We've got our UN Human Rights Council membership to consider, and only Abhisit's slick thinkspeak will keep us in the clear.


by laoguy
on 07/20/2010 08:05 am

#Anonymous The message is even handed. Too even handed. It suggests everyone should take some of the blame. That of course includes the guy at the top. And I am not referring to
to Prem. Intimating that this unmentionable person could do wrong is against the law. Or another way. The law is against this type of criticism.


by Anonymous
on 07/22/2010 08:41 am

Please utilize the spellcheck function before posting. The word is "ruckus."




Name:

E-mail:
(optional)
Comment:

Allowed HTML tags: <B></B>, <I></I>, <A></A>
Are you human? 




designed by Fusion