Inside Scoop Breaking News Video Blog Index Humor
Home Bangkok Pundit Minister threatens to close down ISPs and DSI to go after Bloomberg
+ Follow Me

Bangkok Pundit

BP

Location: Bangkok, Thailand

My Posts | My RSS feed


Minister threatens to close down ISPs and DSI to go after Bloomberg

Minister threatens to close down ISPs and DSI to go after Bloomberg
+ enlarge
Nov. 04 2009 - 06:59 pm
View comments (7)

0


First, the police arrested a third person for allegedly spreading rumors about HM the King's health. As the Bangkok Post reports:

A third person has been arrested and charged with involvement in the spreading of rumours that caused a sharp drop in the stock market.

Somjate Itthiworakul, 38, was detained in Chon Buri's Bang Lamung district yesterday after the Criminal Court approved a warrant for his arrest.

Mr Somjate was taken for questioning at the Central Investigation Bureau's Hi-Tech Crime Centre where he was charged under the 2007 Computer Offences Act of posting misleading information which could pose a threat to national security.

BP: One question has always been, if they could arrest some of these people for translating foreign language news reports, why won't they go after the foreign news agencies? Well, it seems the authorities are considering this, as Post Today reports. A DSI source is quoted as stating that DSI [equivalent of FBI] is considering taking action against a foreign news agency for spreading rumors. The news article was inauspicious and created panic in the stock market

The DSI source said that they had discussed bringing charges against the foreign news agency that focuses on economic matters that has an office in Hong Kong and the agency may be charged because it disseminated inauspicious news and this is deemed as being wrong. However, it is quite sensitive and Thailand may come under attack by other news agencies for doing so. Therefore, the DSI must consider the matter carefully.

BP: This is in reference to Bloomberg, who were the first to report the story that rumors over HM the King's health had caused the stock market to fall. The authorities seem to be in a bind. It is double standards to arrest someone for translating a news article and they can rest assured that going after journalists would raise the stakes.

Finally, the the minister in charge of IT threatens ISPs. Prachatai translates this Thai Rath interview with the minister:

It was found that Theeranan Wiphuchanin might have posted the translation only on the website which was the source of the rumour [Prachatai webboard].  But Katha Pachachariyapong was found to have posted the ‘inauspicious’ content on many websites, and forwarded it to his stock-brokering friends, of whom at least two people had further forwarded the message. They will be charged under the 2007 Computer Crimes Act, the Minister said.

Regarding action against the source website of the rumour [Prachatai] where Theeranan posted her translation, Ranongrak said that she had to wait for the findings of the police first. If the website is found to have links with the ‘rumour-mongering gang’, the webmaster will be prosecuted under the 2007 Computer Crimes Act, facing the penalty of up to 5 years in jail or a fine of 100,000 baht, or both, she said.

The MICT has contacted the ISPs which provide services to the websites [Prachatai and Fah Diew Kan] and informed them that if they still allow these websites which have had a record of being ‘subversive to national security’ to continue, the Ministry will close down those ISPs.

BP: This is insane. It becomes more difficult to interpret the arrest of the two persons on Sunday for posting messages to Prachatai and SameSky (instead of targeting other sites which also carried the Bloomberg report) as anything other than a means to shut down the two sites. Korn's comments the other day on the arrests are even more relevant:

"ใน ส่วนของเว็บไซต์ที่เผยแพร่ข้อมูลนั้น ที่ผ่านมามักจะมีบทบาทเผยแพร่ข้อมูลล่อแหลมทั้งต่อการเมืองและความมั่นคงของ ประเทศ และครั้งนี้ก็คงนำเสนอข้อมูลที่ผิดสังเกตจนนำไปสู่การจับกุมของตำรวจ ซึ่งน่าจะเป็นบทเรียนในอนาคต ส่วนจะถึงขั้นสั่งปิดเว็บหรือไม่ คงต้องขึ้นกับกระทรวงไอซีทีและกฎหมายที่เกี่ยวข้อง"

["For the websites who disseminated the information, in the past they usually have the role of disseminating dangerous/dicey information about politics and national security. This time it is unusual to the extent that they are arrested by the police. It is likely a lesson for the future. Regarding closing down the websites, it will be up to the Ministry of ICT and related laws."]

BP: Is this anything other than a threat? How many more will be arrested? How many more websites will be threatened with shutdowns? How many media organizations will protest?

btw, anyone notice that the papers no longer refer to it as "rumours over HM the King's health"? It is now "inauspicious news". Afraid to say what it is?



  Comment It |     |    Email it    Print it   


Related Stories


Google, Microsoft and Yahoo come together to remove duplicate content on the web (story by Indianomics)
Billions and Billions (story by Atanu Dey on India's Development)
N. Korea Terrorism and Thailand Terrorism: Hillary’s Solution? (story by Thai Intelligent News)
Defamation of Rama 5th, got Military to Huff and Puff only (story by Thai Intelligent News)
An Update on the Greens and Juthamas Bribery Case (story by Bangkok Pundit)
PAD and Violence UPDATE YouTube Video added (story by Bangkok Pundit)


Comments



by StanG
on 11/04/2009 08:25 pm
http://siampolitics.wordpress.com/

Don't forget that the rumors cost the country some real money and that is the real reason for the crackdown, not the LM offenses.

The threat to ISP is ridiculous. The minister probably meant the hosting company, dotarai.com, but you never know - they select top grade imbeciles for the ICP ministry, brought to you by cabinet quota system.


by Veharachan
on 11/04/2009 08:58 pm

I am afraid DSI will not take any action against Bloomberg. The news agency did not spread the rumor with the intent to bring down SET or with reckless disregard in doing so. It reported that the rumor caused or might have caused SET stocks to slide. Not only that, Bloomberg article hit the wires after the fact; SET stocks had already fallen.

As a country we don't want to appear irrational or xenophobic. One final point, there are no stock markets in the world which are insulated from rumors, whispers, half truths or "headline risks". Traders, speculators and investors all operate in the world of incomplete information. If you have complete information, you are an insider. The law will set limits on the manner you can trade.


by Reg
on 11/04/2009 09:54 pm

All of the arresting is a fake. What we have is an increasingly repressive and authoritarian government just wanting to close down what is left of the critical mainstream media. I say mainstream because they aren't yet going after the red media. They will do this after the potentially critical mainstream voices are silenced. This is the slippery road to Thai-style fascism.


by Ricefield Radio
on 11/05/2009 12:10 am
http://ricefieldradio.com

The stock market is based on speculation, assumptions and guessing. Those that are big players in the market always share information, that's a stock market, that's what is involved.

For fear of being on the next hit list, the Royal Household Bureau released what appeared to be conflicting status reports and the Government put 18,000 troops on the street. What were people to make of that? It's only natural that people were talking about HM's health and condition.

Reg is correct in his assumption that this government is trying to stifle comment by not only the media but by the population at large.


by StanG
on 11/05/2009 08:58 am
http://siampolitics.wordpress.com/

According to The Nation, Ekkachai Anchanabutr's own investigation pointed to some "Jor", a fund manager, who's made 5 billion from the rumor.

Even if Ekkachai is exaggerating and only, say, 1 billion was made in two or three days - not bad a profit.

The content of the rumor itself is irrelevant, they just picked up on whatever was most effective at the time.


by Moon Willow
on 11/05/2009 10:30 am

Can anyone explain me why the rumors took place because the main media in Thailand is not credible?


by Mithran
on 11/05/2009 01:23 pm

"websites which have had a record of being ‘subversive to national security’"

Therefore the onus is now on the MICT to prove that Prachatai *are* being subversive to national security.

Considering the translation was posted after the markets shut, that's not going to be too easy, is it?




Name:

E-mail:
(optional)
Comment:

Allowed HTML tags: <B></B>, <I></I>, <A></A>
Are you humanoid? 




designed by Fusion